Quantcast

digital ghettos

Published 25 February 08 05:13 AM | jtspencer 

The Digital Divide is not a large chasm separating the "haves" and "have nots."  The notion that we can simply fill this chasm with resources and make a bridge is a failure in metaphor.  Technologically, lower-income and middle-income students live in separate worlds.  It is less of a chasm and more of a massive wall - perhaps an invisible wall; one so deceptively invisible that low income children can believe they are participating in the Digital Age when they sign up for a myspace account.

The reality is that low-income students often inhabit digital ghettos that prevent them from accessing, analyzing and applying the resources needed to thrive in a global economy. Yet, what are the walls that prevent integration?  Technology segregation is not as simple as the former "whites only" signs that were once posted all over the Deep South.  

Ghetto Walls:

1. Lack of Access - Although many schools have new technology, the students do not have access to these media because teachers rarely integrate technology into lessons.  In many schools, the issue is a simple re-organization of computers.  For others, it is switching from proprietary software to open source and freeware.  Still, for others, the issue of access is not accessing the technology, but accessing the professional development.  They don't know where to go to learn more.

2. Lack of Motivation - Some teachers and students do not want to use technology.  It can seem like a fiery, mysterious box.  It can feel too complicated and foreign.  For some, it can seem like a waste of time in the greater battle of "student achievement."  As one teacher in my school put it, "Why should we use computers if we will be tested with paper and pencil?" 

3. Lack of Self-Efficacy - Many teachers and students believe that they can't learn computers.  They have few opportunities to use it and so they never try.  Past experiences taught them that it's too hard and so now they avoid trying rather than being embaressed or dissapointed.

4. Beliefs - For some teachers, it's an issue of a paradigm shift (segregation to integration).  For others, it's a matter of seeing the connection between educational theory and the available technology.

 

Comments
# Betty said on February 25, 2008 8:46 AM:

I had students who did not have computers at home, and therefore, couldn't compete with their peers when it came to technology.  Although I tried, I was also technology deprived.  I did use technology in my classes as much as I could, but the lack of friendly support prevented me from doing all that I could.  When I think about my computer inservices now, I get mad.  One instructor actually slapped my hand and told me to leave the computer alone and watch the person next to me!  One thing that did help me was calling on some of my tech savvy students for help.  

# vegas art guy said on February 29, 2008 8:27 AM:

It could also be that students destroyed a bunch of equipment in the computer lab and the school decided that it wasn't worth the headache to replace them.

And I salute you for teaching 7th graders, because they're one of two things: Angels or Demon Spawn... lol

I'll be adding you to my blog roll as well...

# The Virtual Teacher said on March 4, 2008 9:59 PM:

We have a one-to-one laptop program for our students (grades 3-11).  The students can take their laptops home and use them for their assignments.  They can also use them for other purposes.  This still does not cure the divide.

The problem is that many of the students from less privileged families do not have backgrounds with technology.  They are far more tentative with with the laptops than those who have always had technology at home.  Many do not have access to the internet from home.  The few who use their machines beyond the course requirements are playing games.  Even Facebook, IMs and blogs tend to happen on home machines, not the school laptops.

Even when students have access and teachers use the technology effectively and believe in its importance, there is still a divide.

I am glad to see you defining this as a multi-faceted issue.

# Erika K. said on July 30, 2008 3:07 PM:

I think technology is such an important part of students lives today and should be implemented as much as possible by the educator. I believe it is very important to teach your students as much as you know about different types of technology and how they can use them. Because there is the issue of the digital divide their are so many students that  learn about technology solely at school. Technology is becoming more and more part of the everyday life and it is so important that we as educators try to incorporate technology into these students lives, that they might not get to experience at home.

Leave a Comment

(required) 
(optional)
(required) 
 

About jtspencer

I am a teacher in an inner-city Phoenix school. I'm not a big fan of online anonymity, so I'll tell you exactly who I am: I teach seventh and eighth grade social studies at Frank Borman Middle School. I love teaching, but I also know that it can be challenging. I am married and have two sons.